Pro Silva Ireland

PRO SILVA POLAND VISIT 2015: An account of forest discussions

March 2, 2016


A recent report by ProSilva committee members Jonathan Spazzi with the collaboration of Kevin O’Connell (Teagasc), and Charlie Tailor (FC Scotland)

This visit took place between the 24 and 27 June as a joint effort of ProSilva Ireland and the Continuous Cover Forestry Group (CCFG) UK. During our visit networking and discussion between members of the two groups were a very positive feature and hopefully something that will continue in future tours.


The tour was excellently hosted by Maciej Pach, Silviculturalist from the experimental forestry unit in the University of Agriculture, Krakow, Poland and took us to visit a range of remarkable forest in the south of Poland:

  • Experimental Forestry Unit (EFU) in Krynica Zdrój (Beskid Sadecki Mountains – the Carpathians)
  • “Łabowiec” reserve – a natural primeval forest composed of Abies alba and Fagus sylvatica and visit nearby Beech seed stands
  • “Obroźyska” reserve – A coppice with standards Lime (Tilia cordata) forest.
  • Szczawiczne – conversion of Scots pine nurse crop to stand composed of target tree species (Abies alba, Fagus sylvatica and Picea abies).
  • Mrokowiec – Abies alba stand managed by selection system
  • Krynica – visit a stand managed by the Swiss irregular shelterwood system – sightseeing


The sections below attempt to capture the main topics from the many discussions we had during our forest visits.



The Labowiec reserve has been left to evolve for the last 100 years with regular monitoring as way to learn about natural forest development processes. It is now a magnificent forest with both high levels of biodiversity and volumes of quality timber. It also seems very resilient: a sharp decline of silver fir took place some 10 years ago (acid rain?) and now seems to be making a come back. Dead wood is now 40-50% of stand volume. Increasing deer browsing is a growing problem as it removes most trees’ natural regeneration.


-the importance to designate long term stands – and monitor suitable stands for management learning

-the ability of a forest ecosystem to change/regulate species composition in response to environmental changes

-the importance of dead wood in ecosystem stability (biodiversity)

-the importance to control herbivory

2,1 2.2  2.3




In most of the forest visits the management strategy relied on the strong ability of key species to regenerate under an existing canopy (shade tolerance ) such as silver fir, beech, norway spruce and sycamore. Also, a strong broadleaves component was always present as important for soil quality through its litter deposition.


3.1   3.2



-important to select suitable shade tolerant species in mixtures with our (UK and Ireland) main species (SS,ash) for complex stand development (western red cedar, silver fir, norway spruce, hemlock, sycamore, beech)

-importance of a broadleaves component in conifer stands for soil nutrients cycle and biodiversity (= stability).


Of great interest was the Szczawiczne forest visit. Here foresters started from a green field site 60 years ago with the objective to establish a semi-natural forest (Abies alba, Fagus sylvatica and Picea abies ). Foresters instead of taking the “direct route” by planting target species took a “successional” route and  planted Scots pine as a nurse forest. 60 years later foresters are now “coupe” harvesting and regenerating (planting and natural regeneration) with beech, Norway spruce, sycamore and silver fir.


4.1   4.2



-The importance of considering the long term natural development process when planting a green field site (soil biology development and micro-climate development) by using pioneer species stands or pioneer species in appropriate mixtures with later successional species.

-Is this a reason for a reported general poor performance of “climax” Irish broadleaves new plantations (oak, beech, sycamore) often planted pure on green field sites?


At a Teagasc workshop in Ireland remediating techniques for poorly performing broadleaves plantations involves stumping back sections of plantations and singling the new shoots, as well as inter-planting with complementary species (alder). Results are promising with strong and quality regrowth due to microclimate and improved soil dynamics since planting.



The tour was a very enjoyable experience and certainly a great success from a networking and a learning point of view. If we had to bring home four main point wewould highlight:

  • The great learning value of long term forest monitoring programmes.
  • The relative simplicity and flexibility of  the management system of apparently very complex stands.
  • The high level of species and structural diversity found within this timber production system that offers a great landscape and added value to the local community (well-being and tourism).
  • The comparative smaller scale of harvesting operations in complex stands that offers opportunities for large number of local people to get involved in the tending, harvesting and also enjoyment of the forest.

Share this post:

Related Posts:

2018 Pro Silva Ireland study trip to France in September: now fully booked! Pro Silva Ireland has been delighted with the growing interest in our annual study trips. This year's trip planned for September is now fully subscribed and 24 members will be participating in examining Close-to-Nature managed forests in Eastern France.
Rodney was one of the original founding members of Pro Silva, a signatory of the declaration of Robanov Kot (1989), the Pro Silva founding document. It is his championing of Continuous Cover Forestry (CCF), a term he was instrumental in defining and promoting, that will stand perhaps as his greatest legacy. He was the first chairman of the Continuous Cover Forestry Group (CCFG) and was responsible for establishing a formal association with ProSilva.
The focus of the Pro Silva Ireland Autumn field day will be early management of 1st generation oak plantation. We will be joined on the day by the Head Cooper from Irish Distillers in Middleton Co. Cork. Ger is a 5th generation cooper who has spent his life working with oak and knows the quality requirements of oak for coopering better than anyone. In recent years, Irish Distillers have been working with Pro Silva Ireland members to sustainably source high quality oak for coopering.
Phil Morgan, President of ProSilva Europe and known to many ProSilva Ireland members recently wrote an article on "The Case for Continuous Cover Forestry". The Forestry & Timber News Journal has kindly allowed us to re-publish the article here.